Latest news

The Fiducia team's latest views on AML/CFT in New Zealand

Latest News/ 2017-09-08T14:45:52+00:00 September 7th, 2017|

The Commonwealth Bank money laundering scandal: where did it all go wrong?

The Commonwealth Bank (CBA) has landed itself in a world of hurt following the recent AUSTRAC money laundering revelations.

With nearly 54,000 alleged breaches of the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Act 2006,

CBA is in the firing line for, wait for it…

….nearly one trillion dollars in fines.

Welcome to the new world of AML/CFT enforcement, everybody.

What happened?

There are two primary factors at play here.

Firstly, money laundering and terrorist financing may have actually been taking place by some of the bank’s customers. The centre of the problem appears to be CBA’s intelligent deposit machines. These ambiguous depository systems allow customers to drop bundles of cash into a box which quickly accredits their bank accounts. 

There have been more than a couple allegations that drug syndicates took advantage of the anonymous nature of these machines. Sound like a Scorcese film yet? It gets better (worse).

CBA’s anti-money laundering compliance measures simply weren’t working. CBA were not checking high risk customers’ sources of wealth (known in New Zealand as enhanced due diligence). They were failing to file reports to the police within the required time-frames, and they weren’t doing much about alerts raised by staff within the bank either.

That, on top of more general allegations that CBA has not been following it’s own compliance documentation for the last few years. Yikes.

This is an interesting conundrum that they’ve found themselves in. Money laundering and anti-money laundering compliance requirements are two separate things. Money laundering is dealt with through criminal proceedings, while failing to meet AML compliance requirements can result in either criminal or civil proceedings.

They’ve got allegations of both ends of the spectrum, along with a possible wider review of the ethical conduct of CBA. They’re in a hell of a pickle.

So what does this mean for AML/CFT in New Zealand?

We’ve seen a very small appetite for public formal warnings for breaches of the AML/CFT Act to date. While some prosecutions of small firms have been filed, we are yet to hear of any fines or convictions in New Zealand.

New Zealand AML/CFT regulators have been focused on educating and empowering reporting entities. In our experience, they would rather agree on a remediation plan with our clients than seek to punish them.

This approach only works when our clients familiarise themselves with the rules and are open to being proactive and totally transparent with their supervisor.

Despite this, it is frustrating for the majority of reporting entities in New Zealand to spend time and money maintaining AML/CFT compliance while their competitors commercially benefit from loose or non-existent compliance regimes. We’ve all got a story of a business who seems to be getting away with it.

Within days of the AUSTRAC action being announced, CBA released huge profit statements on the back of a 4.3 percent rise in banking revenue. Billions of dollars in profits, made possible in part by a dysfunctional compliance regime which allowed nearly 54,000 dirty transactions.

New Zealand supervisors cannot let this happen here.

Fiducia is New Zealand’s most trusted AML/CFT compliance specialists.
We take care of your compliance needs so that you can get back to business.
Contact us today.

Hey! This fine print matters! Any content that you’re accessing here may be inaccurate, incomplete or outdated. The reasons for this include that only the New Zealand AML/CFT regulators can tell you what constitutes AML/CFT compliance. Their guidance continues to develop as the regime develops and matures. Your use and interpretation of any content on this site is your responsibility and is at your own risk. This content does not constitute investment or financial advice, taxation advice, accounting advice or legal advice, and use of our services does not establish a fiduciary relationship of any kind.  See Section 9 of our Terms and Conditions for all information relating to your use of the content on this site.